Computational protein design with evolutionary-based and physics-inspired modeling: current and future synergies

Computational protein design facilitates discovery of novel proteins with prescribed structure and functionality. Exciting designs were recently reported using novel data-driven methodologies that can be roughly divided into two categories: evolutionary-based and physics-inspired approaches. The former infer characteristic sequence features shared by sets of evolutionary-related proteins, such as conserved or coevolving positions, and recombine them to generate candidates with similar structure and function. The latter estimate key biochemical properties such as structure free energy, conformational entropy or binding affinities using machine learning surrogates, and optimize them to yield improved designs. Here, we review recent progress along both tracks, discuss their strengths and weaknesses, and highlight opportunities for synergistic approaches

Improving sequence-based modeling of protein families using secondary structure quality assessment

Motivation: Modeling of protein family sequence distribution from homologous sequence data recently received considerable attention, in particular for structure and function predictions, as well as for protein design. In particular, Direct Coupling Analysis, a method to infer effective pairwise interactions between residues, was shown to capture important structural constraints and to successfully generate functional protein sequences. Building on this and other graphical models, we introduce a new framework to assess the quality of the secondary structures of the generated sequences with respect to reference structures for the family. Results: We introduce two scoring functions characterizing the likeliness of the secondary structure of a protein sequence to match a reference structure, called Dot Product and Pattern Matching. We test these scores on published experimental protein mutagenesis and design dataset, and show improvement in the detection of non-functional sequences. We also show that use of these scores help rejecting non-functional sequences generated by graphical models (Restricted Boltzmann Machines) learned from homologous sequence alignments

Computational design of novel Cas9 PAM-interacting domains using evolution-based modelling and structural quality assessment.

We present here an approach to protein design that combines (i) scarce functional information such as experimental data (ii) evolutionary information learned from a natural sequence variants and (iii) physics-grounded modeling. Using a Restricted Boltzmann Machine (RBM), we learn a sequence model of a protein family. We use semi-supervision to leverage available functional information during the RBM training. We then propose a strategy to explore the protein representation space that can be informed by external models such as an empirical force-field method (FoldX). Our approach is applied to a domain of the Cas9 protein responsible for recognition of a short DNA motif. We experimentally assess the functionality of 71 variants generated to explore a range of RBM and FoldX energies. Sequences with as many as 50 differences (20% of the protein domain) to the wild-type retained functionality. Overall, 21/71 sequences designed with our method were functional. Interestingly, 6/71 sequences showed an improved activity in comparison with the original wild-type protein sequence. These results demonstrate the interest in further exploring the synergies between machine-learning of protein sequence representations and physics grounded modeling strategies informed by structural information